Jun 26th 2024, 2:02:11
Keep ANW. But make a "combined title" that uses all relevant metrics; members, TNW, ANW, T10 countries, top rank and the alliance that scores the lowest sum of combined ranks in all of these gets put first. that way if you drop members you might gain on ANW but since you lose tnw and members its not very clear if its even an advantage for you.
Example
Clan A is
4th in ANW
top country ranked 1st
3rd in members
2nd in TNW
3rd in number of top 10 countries
So they get 4+1+3+2+3 = 13 in score which is a very strong score that might make them #1 or #2 among all clans (lower score is better)
If they drop 2 low ranked members they might be 4th in members, and they might even get a worse TNW rank, even if they get up to 3rd in ANW.
You can always make it so that you cant drop people unless its before the last 10 days or something, thereby making it a very difficult choice that most leaders wont see a reason to do.
So it's like golf, lowest score wins?
I like the idea someone else had with records/cumulative score keeping from round to round, giving people a reason to keep working for a clan, creating a legacy. If the scores are boiled down to 'points' so to speak, the points aren't norm referenced or anything, so they become meaningless across sets. Only downside to that option, I think.